A lower purchase APR can still cost more if its annual fee outweighs the interest savings on the balance you expect to carry. Compare the same balance over the same period, then add the relevant fees. If you pay purchases in full and retain a grace period, a lower purchase APR may provide little immediate value.
This educational worksheet compares hypothetical terms, not current offers, approval chances or a recommendation to borrow. It is for U.S. readers evaluating ongoing borrowing costs; it is separate from a rewards comparison that assumes no interest.
Copy the right rate from the offer
CFPB and FDIC guidance distinguishes purchase, balance-transfer and cash-advance pricing and explains that promotional terms can end. Copy the rate for the transaction you actually plan to make. Also record the post-promotion rate, annual fee, transaction fees and the terms for avoiding purchase interest. Do not assume a card advertised as low-interest has one rate for every transaction.
| Offer detail | Card A | Card B |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase APR applicable to you | ___ | ___ |
| Introductory rate and end date, if any | ___ | ___ |
| Post-introductory APR or range | ___ | ___ |
| Annual fee charged in the comparison period | ___ | ___ |
| Relevant transaction fees | ___ | ___ |
| Planned payments and purchase dates | Same schedule | Same schedule |
A simple comparison, with its limits
For an initial screen, approximate interest as average interest-bearing balance × APR × months ÷ 12. Add the annual fee actually charged and any relevant transaction fee. This is a simple-interest estimate, not an issuer statement calculation: daily balances, compounding, payment timing, grace periods and multiple balance types can change the result.
| Six-month illustration | Card A | Card B |
|---|---|---|
| Assumed average interest-bearing balance | $2,000 | $2,000 |
| Hypothetical purchase APR | 24% | 18% |
| Simple interest estimate | $2,000 × 0.24 × 6/12 = $240 | $2,000 × 0.18 × 6/12 = $180 |
| Annual fee charged during the period | $0 | $95 |
| Interest estimate plus fee | $240 | $275 |
Card B saves an estimated $60 of interest but adds $95 in fees, making this limited six-month comparison $35 more expensive. The $2,000 is an assumed average balance, not a starting balance that remains unchanged despite repayments. Principal payments are excluded because they repay money borrowed rather than represent borrowing cost.
Find the break-even balance
With a 6-percentage-point APR difference over six months, each dollar of average balance saves about $0.03 in this simplified model. A $95 extra fee therefore needs roughly $95 ÷ 0.03 = $3,166.67 of average interest-bearing balance to break even. This is a comparison threshold, not a reason to keep a larger debt.
Over a full year the same calculation gives $95 ÷ 0.06 = $1,583.33. A faster payoff reduces average balance and changes the answer. If the APR difference is zero, there is no interest-saving break-even; if the supposedly cheaper card has the higher APR, this calculation does not apply.
Test the repayment plan before applying
Use your actual planned payments to build a month-by-month balance estimate, then check the offer’s method. If moving an existing balance, include the transfer fee and verify the transfer APR and deadline; the purchase APR alone is not enough. Do not count uncertain future rewards as money available for the next payment.
For the mechanics behind the estimate, read how credit-card interest works. If the issue is an unaffordable minimum payment, use the hardship-call and cash-plan worksheet before treating a new application as a solution.
Sources and assumptions
Sources checked November 17, 2026: CFPB credit-card terms and FDIC credit-card comparison guidance. All rates, fees and balances in the worked example are invented for arithmetic. Verify your own agreement; this is not personalized financial or legal advice.